Layla vs. Casper (2026): Which Foam Mattress Is the Better Fit?

Layla and Casper both sell all-foam mattresses online. Layla's flips between soft and firm; Casper's all-foam bed, The One, has a single medium-firm feel and a shorter warranty.

Updated November 2026 · By the Top Mattresses Today Editorial Team

Layla vs. Casper at a Glance

Layla Memory Foam Casper The One (all-foam)
Height 10.5" 11"
Layers Two-sided: copper-gel memory foam on both sides of a support core Three foam layers: breathable polyfoam, memory foam, polyfoam base
Firmness Soft side and firm side Medium-firm
Support Two-sided core Continuous support
Trial 120 nights 100 nights (30-night adjustment period)
Warranty Lifetime 10-year limited
Hybrid version Layla Hybrid (flippable) Casper Dream (12" hybrid) and Snow

Specs are from each brand's site when we checked in November 2026. Casper isn't one of our affiliate partners, so we don't link to it.

Construction Compared

Soft white foam texture

Layla puts copper-gel-infused memory foam on both sides of a support core. The soft side has a thicker layer for more sink; the firm side a thinner one for more support. Flip the mattress to change the feel. Layla says it's fiberglass-free.

Casper's all-foam mattress, The One, uses three layers: a breathable polyfoam top, memory foam in the middle and a polyfoam base. Casper describes the feel as responsive and lively, with a medium-firm rating.

Feel and Firmness

Casper's top layer of polyfoam over memory foam gives a quicker, springier response than a memory foam top. Layla's memory foam surface gives a deeper, slower hug, especially on the soft side. If you dislike the "stuck in foam" feeling, Casper's construction may suit you; if you want cradling pressure relief, Layla does.

Trial and Warranty

Layla offers a longer trial and a lifetime warranty compared with Casper's 100 nights and 10-year limited warranty on its all-foam bed. Casper requires 30 nights before you can start a return.

Which Is Better for Your Sleep Position?

Sleeper Layla Casper The One
Side, lighter Soft side Medium-firm can feel firm
Side, heavier Firm side or hybrid Often fine
Back Firm side Good fit
Stomach Firm side Good for average weights
Combination Either; memory foam is slower to move on Responsive top makes moving easier

Cooling and Couples

Both are all-foam beds, which hold more heat than coil hybrids. Layla infuses its foam with copper gel; Casper uses a breathable polyfoam top layer. Both absorb motion well. For more airflow, compare the brands' hybrids. See our memory foam vs. hybrid guide.

Lower Back Pain and Pressure Relief

Research reviews have generally found that medium-firm mattresses suit many people with lower back pain, but comfort is personal. Casper's single medium-firm feel lands in that range. Layla's firm side does too, while its soft side gives more cushioning at the shoulders and hips for side sleepers. If pain is persistent or severe, talk to a doctor or physical therapist. See our best type of mattress for lower back pain guide.

Edge Support

All-foam edges compress more than reinforced coil edges, so you'll sink further sitting on the side of either bed. If you sit on the edge to dress or need a firm edge to stand up, look at hybrids. The Layla Hybrid uses a double row of perimeter coils. See our best mattress for seniors guide.

Price and Value

Both sell in the mid-range bed-in-a-box tier and run frequent sales, so the gap between them changes through the year. The One is one of Casper's lower-priced models. Layla's case for value is two firmness levels in one bed and a lifetime warranty. Compare current prices, trial length and return terms before you buy. See our best mattress under $1,000 guide.

Who Should Choose Layla?

Flippable memory foam
Layla Memory Foam Mattress

Best for: Budget shoppers who want two firmness options in one bed

TypeFlippable memory foam
Height10.5"
FirmnessSoft side and firm side
FoamCopper-gel-infused high-resilience memory foam
CertificationsCertiPUR-US
FiberglassNone, per Layla
Trial120 nights
WarrantyLifetime
Pros
  • Flip it to switch between soft and firm
  • Fiberglass-free, per Layla
  • Lifetime warranty
Cons
  • Memory foam feel isn't for everyone
  • Not latex or organic
  • Side sleepers who want a soft side
  • Anyone unsure of their ideal firmness
  • Buyers who want a lifetime warranty

See our Layla review.

Who Should Choose Casper?

Living room with a tufted gray sofa
  • Back and combination sleepers who like medium-firm
  • People who prefer a more responsive foam feel
  • Buyers who want to try in person at retail partners

See our Casper King review and our Casper alternatives guide.

Want Coils?

Flippable hybrid
Layla Hybrid Mattress

Best for: Shoppers who want flippable firmness plus the support of coils

TypeFlippable hybrid
Height13"
FirmnessSoft side and firm side
SupportIndividually wrapped coils with a double row of 16-gauge perimeter coils
FoamCopper-gel-infused memory foam
Trial120 nights
WarrantyLifetime
Pros
  • Both firmness options in one mattress
  • Reinforced perimeter coils for edge support
  • Coils add airflow over all-foam
Cons
  • Heavier to flip than the all-foam Layla
  • Memory foam comfort layers, not latex

The Layla Hybrid keeps the flippable design over pocketed coils with reinforced edges.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Layla or Casper Firmer?

Casper's all-foam mattress has one medium-firm feel. Layla has a soft side and a firm side, so it can be softer or firmer than Casper depending on which side is up.

Which Has the Longer Warranty?

Layla offers a lifetime warranty. Casper lists a 10-year limited warranty on its all-foam mattress.

Which Has the Longer Trial?

Layla offers 120 nights. Casper lists a 100-night trial with a 30-night adjustment period before returns.

Does Casper Have Zoned Support?

Casper lists continuous (not zoned) support on its all-foam mattress. Zoned support appears on its Dream hybrid.

Which Is Better for Side Sleepers?

Layla's soft side gives side sleepers more cushioning than a single medium-firm feel.

The Bottom Line

Choose Layla for two firmness levels, a longer trial and a lifetime warranty. Choose Casper if you want a single, responsive medium-firm foam feel. See also Layla vs. Nectar and Layla vs. Puffy.

Our top pick is the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss: certified organic latex in Medium or Medium-Firm, with a comfort exchange if you need it.

View Botanical Bliss