Is Your Mattress Too Firm?
Signs your mattress may be too firm:
- Sore shoulders, hips or arms when you wake
- Numbness or tingling in pressure points
- Tossing and turning to get comfortable
- No sinkage at the shoulders and hips; Tom's Guide says there should be some when you lie on it
Firm mattresses suit many back, stomach and heavier sleepers, but side sleepers and lighter people often need more cushioning. See our mattress firmness scale.
8 Ways to Make a Mattress Softer

1. Give it time to break in. New mattresses soften with use. Amerisleep says most get a little softer within the first 50 to 60 nights. See how to break in a new mattress.
2. Add a soft mattress topper. This is the most effective fix. Sleepopolis suggests toppers made of memory foam, polyfoam, wool or latex.
3. Warm up the room. Memory foam softens with warmth. Sleep Advisor notes a warm room makes it softer and a cold room makes it harder. Stay within a comfortable sleeping temperature.
4. Check your base. Sleep Foundation says hard, inflexible bases, including many box springs and solid platforms, can make a mattress feel firmer, while a base with more flexible slats may add some give. Check your warranty before switching. See do you need a box spring?
5. Flip it, if it's designed to be flipped. Some mattresses have a softer side. Saatva lists flipping among its tips, but only for double-sided mattresses. See how often to rotate or flip a mattress.
6. Walk or roll on it gently. Casper suggests applying weight when you're not sleeping to help a firm mattress break in faster. Spread your weight evenly.
7. Try a heated mattress pad. Sleep Foundation suggests this for memory foam beds. Follow the manufacturer's safety instructions.
8. Use your sleep trial. If nothing works, return or exchange it before the trial ends. See mattress sleep trials and warranties.
Choosing a Topper to Soften a Mattress
| Topper Material | Feel | Good For |
|---|---|---|
| Memory foam | Deep, slow contouring | Side sleepers who want a hug |
| Soft latex | Buoyant cushioning | Hot sleepers; combination sleepers |
| Wool | Light, breathable padding | Adding plushness without much sink |
| Polyfoam / egg crate | Budget cushioning | Short-term or guest beds |
Thickness matters. A thin pad adds little; Tom's Guide suggests looking for plush toppers around 4 inches thick to soften a hard mattress noticeably.
Best for: Most sleepers who want natural, durable cushioning or firmness, with the widest firmness choice
| Type | Organic latex topper |
|---|---|
| Material | GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex |
| Thickness | 2" or 3" |
| Firmness | Soft to Extra-Firm (five options listed when we checked) |
| Sizes | Twin to Cal King |
| Cover | Optional GOTS organic cotton cover, sold separately |
| Certifications | GOLS, OEKO-TEX Standard 100, GREENGUARD Gold |
| Trial | Not returnable once opened, per PlushBeds |
| Warranty | 5-year limited |
- Widest firmness range of the toppers we cover, from Soft to Extra-Firm
- Certified organic latex with ventilation holes for airflow
- Can soften a firm bed or firm up a soft one, depending on the firmness you choose
- Not returnable once opened, so choose firmness carefully
- Cover is an extra purchase
- Latex is heavy compared with foam toppers
Best for: Value-minded shoppers who want certified organic latex
| Type | Organic latex topper |
|---|---|
| Material | GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex |
| Thickness | 2" or 3" |
| Firmness | Soft, Medium or Medium-Firm |
| Sizes | Twin to Cal King |
| Cover | Optional GOTS organic cotton cover |
| Certifications | GOLS latex |
| Trial | See Eco Terra's current terms |
| Warranty | 5-year |
- Certified organic latex from a lower-priced brand
- Three firmness levels and two thicknesses
- Durable and responsive
- No extra-firm option
- Cover sold separately
- Check return terms before buying
See our best mattress topper, best mattress topper for side sleepers and best memory foam mattress topper guides.
What Not to Do
- Don't damage the mattress trying to soften it, such as cutting layers or soaking it.
- Don't use a base your warranty doesn't allow.
- Don't overheat your bedroom just to soften foam; it can disrupt sleep.
When to Replace the Mattress

If the mattress still feels too firm after the break-in period and a good topper, Sleep Foundation says you may be better off replacing it with a softer model. A mattress with adjustable or flippable firmness lets you change the feel later:
Best for: Budget shoppers who want two firmness options in one bed
| Type | Flippable memory foam |
|---|---|
| Height | 10.5" |
| Firmness | Soft side and firm side |
| Foam | Copper-gel-infused high-resilience memory foam |
| Certifications | CertiPUR-US |
| Fiberglass | None, per Layla |
| Trial | 120 nights |
| Warranty | Lifetime |
- Flip it to switch between soft and firm
- Fiberglass-free, per Layla
- Lifetime warranty
- Memory foam feel isn't for everyone
- Not latex or organic
See our best mattress for lightweight sleepers and best mattress for side sleepers guides.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a Firm Mattress Get Softer Over Time?
Yes, somewhat. Amerisleep says mattresses get a little softer in the first 50 to 60 nights of regular use. It won't turn a firm mattress into a soft one, though.
What's the Best Way to Make a Mattress Softer?
A plush topper is usually the quickest and most effective fix. Sleep Advisor calls it one of the quickest, cheapest ways to soften a hard surface.
Does Room Temperature Affect Mattress Firmness?
Yes, for memory foam. It softens in warmth and firms up in the cold.
Can My Bed Base Make My Mattress Feel Firmer?
Yes. Sleep Foundation says hard, inflexible bases such as many box springs and solid platforms can make a mattress feel firmer.
How Do I Know My Mattress Is Too Firm?
Tom's Guide suggests checking for some sinkage around your shoulders and hips. If there's none, the mattress may be too firm for your body.
The Bottom Line
Start by giving a new mattress time to break in. If it's still too firm, add a plush topper, check your base and keep the room comfortably warm for memory foam. If none of that helps, use your sleep trial or choose a softer mattress.
Our top pick is the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss: certified organic latex in Medium or Medium-Firm, with a comfort exchange if you need it.
View Botanical Bliss