Is Your Mattress Too Soft?
Signs your mattress is too soft:
- Your hips sink lower than your shoulders
- Lower back pain or stiffness in the morning
- Feeling "stuck" or having trouble changing position
- Rolling toward the middle or edge
- Visible dips or body impressions
If the problem is sagging rather than a soft feel, see how to fix a sagging mattress.
8 Ways to Make a Mattress Firmer

1. Add a firm topper. Firm latex or high-density foam toppers add support on top. Purple recommends latex toppers if you want a firmer feel along with better durability, temperature regulation and bounce.
2. Use a more supportive base. TechRadar says putting a more supportive frame, platform or base beneath your mattress is a good way to firm it up. Replace broken slats and add center support. See do you need a box spring?
3. Lower the room temperature. Memory foam firms up in cooler air. Tom's Guide says adjusting your thermostat cooler can add firmness to a soft mattress.
4. Rotate it. Rotating moves softer, worn areas away from your hips. Amerisleep includes rotation among its firming tips. See how often to rotate or flip a mattress.
5. Flip it, if it's flippable. Some mattresses have a firmer side. Don't flip a one-sided mattress.
6. Tighten the frame. Tom's Guide notes tightening your bed frame can make a softer mattress feel firmer instantly.
7. Check your trial or warranty. Sleep Foundation suggests checking your sleep trial first. If the mattress is new, an exchange for a firmer model may be the best fix. See mattress sleep trials and warranties.
8. Replace it. Sleep Advisor notes you can only firm up a bed so much, and some fixes are temporary.
Should You Use Plywood or the Floor?
| Method | Effect | Risks |
|---|---|---|
| Plywood under the mattress | Adds a rigid surface; Amerisleep says it can boost support and firmness | Can feel hard, reduce airflow and void some warranties |
| Mattress on the floor | Feels firmer immediately | Check the brand allows it; Tom's Guide warns mold can build up underneath without airing |
Amerisleep cautions that some manufacturers may void your warranty if the mattress isn't on a compatible base. See can you put a mattress on the floor? and mold on mattress.
Choosing a Topper to Firm Up a Mattress

| Topper Material | Firming Effect | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Firm latex | Strong | Durable, cooler, responsive |
| High-density foam | Moderate to strong | Can sleep warm |
| Soft memory foam | None; adds softness | Avoid if you want firmer |
| Wool | Little | Adds comfort, not support |
A topper can't fix deep sagging; it will follow the dip.
Best for: Most sleepers who want natural, durable cushioning or firmness, with the widest firmness choice
| Type | Organic latex topper |
|---|---|
| Material | GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex |
| Thickness | 2" or 3" |
| Firmness | Soft to Extra-Firm (five options listed when we checked) |
| Sizes | Twin to Cal King |
| Cover | Optional GOTS organic cotton cover, sold separately |
| Certifications | GOLS, OEKO-TEX Standard 100, GREENGUARD Gold |
| Trial | Not returnable once opened, per PlushBeds |
| Warranty | 5-year limited |
- Widest firmness range of the toppers we cover, from Soft to Extra-Firm
- Certified organic latex with ventilation holes for airflow
- Can soften a firm bed or firm up a soft one, depending on the firmness you choose
- Not returnable once opened, so choose firmness carefully
- Cover is an extra purchase
- Latex is heavy compared with foam toppers
See our best firm mattress topper guide.
When to Replace the Mattress
If your mattress is sagging, past its expected lifespan or still too soft after these fixes, replace it with a firmer model:
Best for: Back and stomach sleepers and heavier people who want a very firm, hotel-style bed
| Type | Hybrid innerspring |
|---|---|
| Height | 13" |
| Firmness | Firm (Aviya calls it a 'very firm hotel feel') |
| Coils | 1,200 individually wrapped coils (king) |
| Edge | 7.5" x 3" high-density perimeter foam |
| Trial | 100 nights |
| Warranty | 10-year, non-prorated |
| Made in | Cleveland, Ohio |
- A genuinely firm option, not just medium-firm
- Reinforced edges for sitting and sleeping near the edge
- Made in the USA
- Likely too firm for most side sleepers
- Not latex or organic
Best for: Budget shoppers who want two firmness options in one bed
| Type | Flippable memory foam |
|---|---|
| Height | 10.5" |
| Firmness | Soft side and firm side |
| Foam | Copper-gel-infused high-resilience memory foam |
| Certifications | CertiPUR-US |
| Fiberglass | None, per Layla |
| Trial | 120 nights |
| Warranty | Lifetime |
- Flip it to switch between soft and firm
- Fiberglass-free, per Layla
- Lifetime warranty
- Memory foam feel isn't for everyone
- Not latex or organic
The Layla Memory Foam is flippable, with a firmer side if you find the softer side too plush. See our best firm mattress guide and how long does a mattress last?
Health note: If you have ongoing back pain, talk to a doctor or physical therapist. A firmer mattress isn't right for everyone. This page is general information, not medical advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Mattress Topper Make a Bed Firmer?
Yes, if it's a firm topper. Most toppers soften, but firm latex and high-density foam toppers can add support. Purple recommends latex toppers for a firmer feel.
Does Putting a Mattress on the Floor Make It Firmer?
It usually feels firmer, but TechRadar and Tom's Guide warn to check that your mattress can go on the floor, and to air the underside to prevent mold.
Does a Colder Room Make a Mattress Firmer?
For memory foam, yes. Tom's Guide says lowering the thermostat can add firmness to a soft mattress.
Can a Sagging Mattress Be Made Firmer?
Not truly. Sagging is lost support. Fixes like plywood or a firm topper may help temporarily, but a sagging mattress usually needs a warranty claim or replacement.
Why Has My Mattress Gotten Softer?
Saatva notes mattresses can lose firmness over time as their materials naturally soften. A weak or sagging base can also make a mattress feel softer.
The Bottom Line
To firm up a soft mattress, try a firm latex topper, a more supportive base, a cooler room and regular rotation. Plywood and the floor can help but carry risks. If the mattress is sagging or worn out, a warranty claim or a firmer replacement is the real fix.
Our top pick is the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss: certified organic latex in Medium or Medium-Firm, with a comfort exchange if you need it.
View Botanical Bliss