The Best Mattress Protector (2026): Waterproof Protection That Doesn't Crinkle

A good protector keeps spills, sweat and allergens out of your mattress without making noise or trapping heat. Here's our top pick, how the main types compare and what to check before you buy.

Updated November 2026 · By the Top Mattresses Today Editorial Team

Our Top Pick: Sleep & Beyond Organic Cotton Waterproof Protector

A mattress protector is the cheapest insurance you can buy for your mattress. Most warranties exclude stains, and liquids that soak into foam or latex are hard to remove. The best protectors block liquids without crinkling, trapping heat or sliding around.

#1
Organic cotton waterproof protector
Sleep & Beyond Organic Cotton Waterproof Mattress Protector

Best for: Families who want a GOTS organic cotton protector in every size from crib to Cal king

Type5-sided fitted waterproof protector
FabricGOTS organic cotton jersey (200 gsm)
Waterproof layerBio-based TPU film, per Sleep & Beyond
SizesCrib, twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal king, split Cal king
FitsMattresses up to 18" deep (crib up to 6")
CareMachine wash warm; tumble dry low; no ironing
CertificationsGOTS fabric; OEKO-TEX TPU
Warranty10 years
Pros
  • Sizes from crib to Cal king, so siblings can match
  • GOTS organic cotton with a TPU, not vinyl, waterproof layer
  • 10-year warranty
Cons
  • Cut oversized and shrinks over the first few washes
  • High heat can damage the waterproof lining

The Sleep & Beyond protector has a GOTS-certified organic cotton jersey top over a bio-based TPU waterproof layer, per Sleep & Beyond. It's a five-sided fitted design that fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep and comes in every size from crib to California king, including split Cal king. The cotton and TPU layers are certified (GOTS fabric; OEKO-TEX TPU), and it carries a 10-year warranty.

Who it's for: families who want organic cotton, matching protectors across kids' and adults' beds, and anyone with a deep mattress. Note: it's cut slightly oversized to allow for shrinkage, so it may fit loosely until the first wash.

Check Sleep & Beyond Protector Price

Other Protectors Worth Knowing About

We only link to products we can point you to directly. These popular protectors are sold by other brands; we've summarized what reviewers and brands report so you can compare.

Protector Type Notable For
Saatva Waterproof Mattress Protector Fitted, waterproof Organic cotton top over a polyurethane barrier, per reviewers
Bear GlacioTex Protector Fitted, waterproof Cooling fabric; AARP's testers named it best overall
Coop Home Goods Ultra-Tech Fitted, waterproof Budget pick; OEKO-TEX certified; some testers found it warm
SafeRest Premium Fitted or zippered encasement Cotton terry over a waterproof membrane; widely available
Purple Waterproof Protector Fitted, waterproof Tom's Guide testers found it waterproof and quiet

Prices, materials and sizes change, so check each brand's current listing.

Types of Mattress Protectors

Row of washing machines in a laundromat
Type Coverage Best For
Fitted (5-sided) Top and sides Everyday spill and sweat protection
Zippered encasement (6-sided) Whole mattress Bed bugs, dust mite allergies, moving
Strap or elastic-corner Top only Low cost, quick on and off
Waterproof Membrane under top fabric Kids, pets, accidents, night sweats
Non-waterproof (wool, cotton) Fabric layer Breathability, light protection

Learn more in our guide: what is a mattress protector?

What Protectors Are Made Of

Top Fabric Feel Temperature
Organic cotton Soft, natural Breathable
Cotton terry Plush, absorbent Moderate
Tencel / lyocell Smooth, cool Cool
Bamboo-derived rayon Silky Cool to moderate
Polyester Slick, durable Can be warm
Wool Soft, natural Regulates temperature; often not waterproof
Waterproof Layer Notes
TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) Thin, quiet, flexible
Polyurethane (PU) Common, quiet
Vinyl (PVC) Cheap but noisy and warm; many shoppers avoid it

How to Choose a Mattress Protector

Knit sweater on a wooden table
  1. Measure your mattress depth, including any topper. Choose a protector with a pocket at least that deep.
  2. Decide if you need waterproofing. Kids, pets, night sweats and coffee in bed all say yes.
  3. Pick a breathable top if you sleep hot: cotton, Tencel or wool.
  4. Choose an encasement for bed bugs or dust mite allergies.
  5. Check certifications. GOTS (organic fiber) and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 (tested for harmful substances) are common.
  6. Read the care label. High heat can damage waterproof layers.
  7. Buy two so you have a spare while one is in the wash.

Protectors for Special Situations

Situation What to Get
Bedwetting Waterproof fitted protector, plus a spare. See waterproof mattress for bedwetting
Crib mattress Snug, waterproof crib protector; nothing loose in the crib
Latex or organic mattress Organic cotton top with a thin TPU layer
Adjustable base Fitted protector with stretchy sides
Hot sleeper Tencel or cotton top over TPU
Allergies Zippered encasement
Safety note for cribs: Use only a protector made for crib mattresses that fits tightly, and keep the crib free of pillows, blankets and loose bedding.

Caring for a Mattress Protector

  • Wash every one to two months, and right away after spills or illness.
  • Use warm or cool water on a gentle cycle.
  • Tumble dry low; avoid high heat, ironing, bleach and fabric softener.
  • Replace it if the waterproof layer cracks or leaks.

For cleaning the mattress itself, see can you shampoo a mattress?

Protector vs. Pad vs. Topper

Protector Pad Topper
Purpose Protection Light comfort Change the feel
Thickness Very thin Under 2" 2–4"
Waterproof Often Sometimes Rarely

If you want a thin natural layer for comfort rather than waterproofing, a wool pad like the Sleep & Beyond myPad adds breathability without changing firmness:

Wool mattress pad
Sleep & Beyond myPad

Best for: Adding a thin, breathable layer without changing firmness

TypeMattress pad
MaterialWashable wool
Thickness0.5"
FirmnessBarely changes the feel
SizesCrib to Cal King
CoverCotton percale, 270 TC
CertificationsOEKO-TEX Standard 100 (cover and wool)
TrialSee Sleep & Beyond's current terms
Warranty5-year
Pros
  • Thin natural layer that helps manage moisture
  • Fits crib through Cal King
  • 5-year warranty
Cons
  • Won't fix a mattress that's too firm or too soft
  • Not waterproof

See also mattress pad vs. topper and our best mattress topper guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the Best Mattress Protector?

Our top pick is the Sleep & Beyond Organic Cotton Waterproof Protector for its GOTS organic cotton top, TPU waterproof layer, deep fit and sizes from crib to Cal king.

Are Waterproof Mattress Protectors Noisy?

Older vinyl protectors could crinkle. Most modern protectors use thin polyurethane or TPU membranes under a fabric top, which are much quieter.

Do Mattress Protectors Make You Hot?

Some can, especially polyester tops. Cotton, Tencel and wool tops are more breathable. A thin TPU membrane is cooler than thick vinyl.

Do I Need a Protector If My Mattress Has a Removable Cover?

Yes, usually. A removable cover can be washed, but liquids can still soak through into the foam or latex. A waterproof protector stops that.

How Often Should I Replace a Mattress Protector?

When the waterproof layer starts to leak, peel or crack, or the elastic stops holding. Follow the care label to make it last longer.

What Is the Difference Between a Protector and an Encasement?

A fitted protector covers the top and sides. An encasement zips around the entire mattress, which helps with bed bugs and dust mites.

The Bottom Line

A protector is one of the best things you can do for a new mattress. Our top pick is the Sleep & Beyond Organic Cotton Waterproof Protector, with a GOTS organic cotton top, quiet TPU waterproofing, a deep fit and sizes from crib to Cal king. Choose a zippered encasement instead if bed bugs or dust mites are your main concern.

Check Sleep & Beyond Protector Price